Editor's Note: As China's economic growth continues to capture global attention, people tend to ask what a series of economic figures actually means for policy changes and influence on equity markets. Investors usually place their faith in a group of experts: economists. Some people might think economists live in a very different world, and admittedly, the language they use is sometimes hard to penetrate. Shanghai Daily today begins a series in which the "mysterious" people behind the forecasts try to explain their thoughts in a way that can be understood by people who aren't economics-savvy.
For Shen Minggao, chief economist for China at Citigroup, doing forward-looking research is more exciting than retrospective studies because of the intricate variables that make almost anything possible.
Trying to predict the future is a tricky business, especially when the forecasts are aimed at investors who may use the advice in putting their money on the line.
Capabilities tested
"Economists working in financial institutions are directly facing investors, and our capabilities are fairly tested by the market movement. It is fun," said Shen during a lecture at Fudan University last month. Before becoming an economist at Citigroup, Shen was a professor at China's prestigious Peking University.
While many economists rely strictly on analysis tools to forecast macroeconomic trends in China, Shen has what he considers an extra weapon in his arsenal: instinct that is derived from years of experience watching China's economic development unfold.
Intuition, he says, helps untangle the complexities of global and domestic politics, environmental changes, public expectations and other factors that influence how an economy operates.
Last year, Shen successfully predicted Chinese authorities would retreat from their relatively loose policy stance in the third quarter and raise interest rates to sop up excessive market liquidity.
He has also revised his estimate for China's gross domestic product growth to 10 percent from an earlier 9 percent forecast for 2010, based on better-than-expected performance by the world's second-largest economy.
"The most difficult part in my job is to decide how the proportion of these elements, or variables, will work on the nerves of policymakers as well as on the overall economy," Shen said.
Back in 2008, when the Chinese economy was widely believed to be overheating, the subprime mortgage crisis blew up in the United States, creating global turmoil that cooled the Chinese economy. Few analysts had predicted the size and scope of the upheaval.
Analysis tools are helpful, of course. But in China, economists in financial institutions don't usually have immediate access to the kind of detailed economic data necessary to dissect what's going on. Then, too, sometimes the data isn't comprehensive enough to give a wide picture of the economy.
For example, services such as child care and Chinese massage aren't fully reported in the official data, yet both are large sources of consumer spending.
Investors need to be cautious, Shen said.
"Many investors look at results, usually only at several lines in a report, without paying much attention to how the figures are generated," he said." But the process of producing a forecast requires more than mere headline figures."
For some doing research and analysis in China, forecasts may result from pure luck more than any meaningful insight. But that isn't a long-term guarantee of success. Astute economists need to build up their own channels of sources and information, he said.
Aware of uncertainties
When many in the United States are presently suggesting a cautious attitude toward China's economy in the short run and a more optimistic outlook further out, Shen's view is just the reverse.
"China's economy will perform well in the coming months,' he said, "but in the years to come, the country has to cope with the pressure of transforming its economic structure. So investors should be aware of many uncertainties down the road."
Shen said he thinks this year will mark the real beginning of China's efforts to reshape and modernize its economy, although that strategy has been trumpeted for quite a long time.
"China is forced to undergo such a restructuring," according to Shen, "It is pushed by the urgency of a new order that should be established after the global financial crisis."
As a result of the crisis, China has seen demand for its exports dwindle among its traditional trade partners. Hopes that export-led growth would continue to power economic growth have dimmed. The search is on for other ways to fuel economic expansion.
But is China ready to become an economy powered by domestic demand?
Shen thinks not. He said China must first shed its obsession with the idea of growth at 8 percent or stronger and retool its industries to produce products that meet the demands of the growing middle and upper class consumers.
Successful transition
"When the central government sets a target, lower-level governments pull out all the stops to fulfill or even surpass it," he said. "That usually leads to overcapacity, a strain on resources, a deterioration of the environment and delays in the process of economic transformation. For a successful transition, China has to grow slower so that it will make room for structural adjustments."
Bolstering domestic consumption may turn out to be tricky. Because China's social security net is relatively weak, many people may choose to save not spend, he said.
These turbulent times are exciting for an economist, Shen said. He has watched with great interest how the global financial crisis is changing China's thinking and has focused world attention on the nation as never before.
If he were advising Chinese policy makers, Shen said he would suggest sticking to the goal of economic transformation, accelerating the process of urbanization and continuing to address issues like inflation and fair income distribution.
Ordinary people, as a whole, are the biggest variable in his studies, Shen said. For example, the first generation of rural migrants who came to cities looking for work demanded only meagre wages. But now migrant workers are getting bolder and more demanding. If an employer doesn't provide decent lunches, for example, they may turn down a job.
Biography
Shen holds a MA in international development policy and a PhD in economics, both from Stanford University. He was once an associate professor at the China Center for Economic Research at Peking University, where he specialized in development economics.
From 2005 to 2008, Shen was Citigroup's senior China economist. After leaving Citigroup, Shen joined Caijing, a leading Chinese-language political and business magazine, as chief economist.
In August of 2009, Shen was appointed Citigroup's chief economist for China, a newly created position in the bank. Shen is based in Hong Kong, and takes on macroeconomic analysis and research with a primary focus on Chinese mainland.
Hongkong | Tel : +852-2537 7886 | Add : 5/F Manulife Place, 348 Kwun Tong Road, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR |